Post-Election Fracas

The election may be over but the political wrangling continues.

With Republican Christian Russo moving from the Town Board to the county legislature in January, attention is now focused on how his vacant seat will be handled. The Town Board can leave that seat vacant or appoint someone until a special election is held next November.

Last weekend Democrat Maia Gilleo, who garnered 2,243 votes in her race against Russo but fell 137 votes short, announced her interest in taking Russo’s vacant seat. That seems to have sent the Putnam Valley Republican Committee into high gear. 

They circulated an open letter on Facebook asserting that Russo’s seat should only be given to a Republican. Anything else, including leaving the seat empty, would “establish unchecked, one-party rule in Putnam Valley.” The full text of the letter can be viewed here. 

Their assertion seems to ignore the fact that there is still a Republican on the Town Board, Louie Luongo, as well as a Democrat, Sherry Howard, who also ran on the Conservative Party line, receiving more than 400 votes. Though the letter goes on to argue that “Supermajority control fundamentally undermines the health of municipal government,” it makes no mention of three recent years (from 2022 to 2024) when there were four Republicans on the Town Board and one Democrat. 

In their letter, they argue that four Democrats would mean no checks and balances, reduced fiscal accountability and an erosion of public trust. The committee asks that the board instead consider two candidates they have "vetted": Stephanie Waters, who ran and lost in last year’s Republican primary for Town Supervisor after receiving 258 votes, or Abigail O’Brien, who most recently was a paid worker on Kevin Byrne’s campaign for county executive. (Byrne received fewer votes in Putnam Valley than his opponent, Brett Yarris.) Their offer: "The Putnam Valley Republican Committee stands ready to work constructively with the Town Board during this transition."

Town Supervisor Alison Jolicoeur responded to the GOP committee’s letter on her Facebook page with an assurance that no decisions would be made quickly and that party affiliation is not a determining factor. Her full response can be viewed here. She writes: “This Board is committed to a fair, thoughtful, and transparent process. We intend to do our due diligence, carefully consider the responsibilities of the position, and ensure that any decision is made in the best interest of Putnam Valley and its residents.” She asked for time and space to allow the Town Board to do its work. “Our commitment is to the residents of Putnam Valley as a whole, not to any political party or committee. We will approach this matter with the same fairness, integrity, and consideration that residents should expect from their local government.”

Whatever happens, it's a reasonable bet we will see Gilleo, Waters and O'Brien on the campaign trail next year, running for the Town Board.

If you're not already a subscriber but would like to receive future stories, please click on the subscribe button at watchingputnamvalley.com and provide your email address. If you have ideas for future stories or want to provide feedback, please send an email to watchingputnamvalley@gmail.com.